Skip to content

High-Priority Manual Crystallization Batch 2

Why this audit happened

The user requested the second high-priority paper manual crystallization pass before creating new mechanism entity pages. Batch 2 focuses on human lung ILC subset baselines, COPD/smoke-associated plasticity, allergen or cytokine-induced ILC plasticity, and additional neutrophilic or steroid-resistant asthma framing.

Sources revisited

  • 11 high-priority source pages were manually crystallized from extracted title, abstract, early results text, and current wiki context.
  • The batch synthesis has been integrated into Lung ILC Core Evidence Synthesis.
  • The entity hubs ILC2 and ILC3 were updated after batch 1 and batch 2 claims were consolidated.

Page families changed

  • Source pages: 11 high-priority papers upgraded with mature Key Findings, Claim-Level Confidence, Methods and Context, Caveats, and contradiction framing.
  • Digest pages: one new batch 2 digest created.
  • Entity pages: ILC2 and ILC3 hubs updated to hold high-confidence claim anchors from both high-priority digests.
  • Navigation pages: index, digest README, source README, project page, main topic page, and log updated.

Rule or interpretation changes

  • Human lung baseline evidence is now separated from disease mechanism evidence.
  • ILC2 plasticity is now split into memory-like allergic, COPD-associated ILC1-like, IL-17-producing ST2+ ILC2, and human nasal IL-17-producing branches.
  • ILC3 steroid-resistant asthma evidence is separated into primary human airway association, mouse perturbation, and review-level therapeutic target framing.
  • Source Claim-Level Confidence remains claim-centered and does not discuss file presence or extraction status.

Crystallized source pages

Follow-up actions

  • Consider a later focused COPD/smoke digest if those sources become a project priority.
  • Consider mechanism entity pages later for IL-12/IL-18, IL-33/leukotrienes/Ahr, CD45RO memory-like ILC3, SCF/KIT, and ILC-macrophage crosstalk. The user explicitly deferred this step for now.

Reviewer-gate notes

  • Verdict: no blocking accuracy issues detected in the batch-level claims after checking selected extracted source text and existing wiki context.
  • Supported with caveat: human lung and sputum data are mostly association or ex vivo functional evidence; mouse perturbation evidence remains stronger for causal claims.
  • Supported with caveat: nasal ILC2-to-IL-17 plasticity was preserved as human airway/nasal evidence, not lower-lung proof.
  • Supported with caveat: the steroid-resistant asthma review was used for target-space framing and not as primary clinical efficacy evidence.