Skip to content

High-Priority Manual Crystallization Batch 1

Why this audit happened

The user requested high-priority paper manual crystallization after the source pages were corrected to use biological claim confidence rather than file-processing confidence. This batch promotes a focused set of direct lung/airway ILC papers from provisional automated notes into mature source notes and a reusable digest.

Sources revisited

  • 13 high-priority source pages were manually crystallized from extracted title, abstract, early results text, and current wiki context.
  • The batch prioritizes direct lung or airway disease relevance, direct support for current topic/entity pages, and mechanistic importance for ILC2 or ILC3 function.
  • The batch synthesis has been integrated into Lung ILC Core Evidence Synthesis.

Page families changed

  • Source pages: 13 high-priority papers upgraded with mature Key Findings, Claim-Level Confidence, Methods and Context, Caveats, and contradiction framing.
  • Digest pages: one crystallized batch digest added.
  • Navigation pages: index, digest README, project hub, source README, and log updated.

Rule or interpretation changes

  • First-pass mature source notes should preserve source-specific disease context and avoid universal ILC claims.
  • Viral ILC2 biology is now explicitly split into pathogenic AHR, reparative amphiregulin/BATF, IL-1beta braking, and gammaherpesvirus-conditioned macrophage imprinting branches.
  • ILC3 biology is now explicitly split into IL-22 bacterial defense, IGF1 neonatal development, IL-17A ARDS-like pathology, acetylcholine-associated protease allergy, and SCF/KIT neutrophilic asthma branches.

Crystallized source pages

Follow-up actions

  • Manually inspect full figures/methods for the 13 batch-1 papers before manuscript-level wording.
  • Next source-note batch should focus on human lung ILC subset papers, COPD/smoke-associated ILC plasticity, and additional steroid-resistant asthma sources.
  • Consider entity pages for IL33, IL13, amphiregulin, GM-CSF, IL22, IL17A, SCF/KIT, and BATF.

Reviewer-gate notes

  • Verdict: no blocking accuracy issues detected in the batch-level claims after checking the selected extracted source text against the revised source pages and digest.
  • Supported with caveat: human relevance claims were kept weaker than mouse perturbation claims when the source evidence was mouse-dominant or peripheral-blood-dominant.
  • Supported with caveat: the 2011 influenza AHR paper is described as ILC2-like/natural-helper-cell biology because it predates current ILC2 terminology.
  • Supported with caveat: imatinib in the SCF/KIT source is framed as experimental pathway inhibition, not as a clinical recommendation.
  • Residual limitation: OCR artifacts and incomplete PDF extraction remain in some source text; full PDF figure/method review is still required before manuscript-level wording.